100% Official Merchandise
365 Day Returns
  1. MLB
  2. Fanatics Authentic
  3. Collectibles & Memorabilia
  4. Other Collectibles & Memorabilia
  5. Top Fan Gifts
1 - 72 of 254
Top Fan Gifts
Arizona DiamondbacksBaltimore OriolesChicago White SoxCincinnati RedsColorado RockiesDetroit Tigers
254 Items
$33.99
Toronto Blue Jays Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
Most Popular in Collectibles & Memorabilia
Almost Gone!
$1,034.99
Pete Alonso New York Mets Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Blue Nike Hand Guard from the 2025 MLB Season
Almost Gone!
$1,034.99
Pete Alonso New York Mets Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Blue Nike Leg Guard from the 2025 MLB Season
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Black EvoShield Shin Guards vs. New York Mets on May 18, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Navy EvoShield Shin Guards vs. Milwaukee Brewers on March 30, 2025
Almost Gone!
$2,068.99
Paul Goldschmidt New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$2,758.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Pink EvoShield Chest Protector vs. Athletics on May 11, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Cody Bellinger New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$2,413.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Gray EvoShield Shin Guards vs. Pittsburgh Pirates on April 5, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Jazz Chisholm Jr. New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Navy EvoShield Chest Protector vs. Milwaukee Brewers on March 30, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Gray EvoShield Chest Protector vs. Pittsburgh Pirates on April 5, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Pink EvoShield Shin Guards vs. Athletics on May 11, 2025
Almost Gone!
$102.99
Oswald Peraza New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Worn Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Third Base vs. Athletics on June 27-29, 2025
Almost Gone!
$33.99
Cincinnati Reds Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
Most Popular in Collectibles & Memorabilia
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Second Base vs. Baltimore Orioles on June 22, 2025
Almost Gone!
$344.99
Washington Nationals Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Second Base vs. Miami Marlins on June 15, 2025 - Father's Day - Innings 1-3
$33.99
Washington Nationals Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$33.99
Baltimore Orioles Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$33.99
Pittsburgh Pirates Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$33.99
Colorado Rockies Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$33.99
Tampa Bay Rays Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$33.99
Los Angeles Angels Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$33.99
Miami Marlins Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$33.99
Chicago White Sox Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$33.99
Minnesota Twins Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$33.99
Kansas City Royals Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$68.99
Pittsburgh Pirates Fanatics Authentic Team-Issued White Clemente Nameplate from the 2024 MLB Season
Almost Gone!
$33.99
Arizona Diamondbacks Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
$137.99
Los Angeles Dodgers Fanatics Authentic 2024 World Series Champions Crystal Baseball with Game-Used World Series Dirt
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Michael Arias New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #83 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Pablo Reyes New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #19 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Tyler Matzek New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #68 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Geoff Hartlieb New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #64 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Ismael Munguia New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #94 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Alex Jackson New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #39 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Colten Brewer New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #65 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Everson Pereira New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #80 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Brandon Leibrandt New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #89 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Clayton Beeter New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #85 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Jesus Rodriguez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #97 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Yoendrys Gomez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #94 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Brent Headrick New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #97 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Braden Shewmake New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #89 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Roderick Arias New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #84 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Leonardo Pestana New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #84 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Brennen Davis New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #87 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Eric Reyzelman New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #72 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Dominic Smith New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #22 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Erick Leal New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #87 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Ronaldo Hernandez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #66 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Sean Boyle New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #96 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
T.J. Rumfield New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #86 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Omar Martinez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #88 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Wilking Rodríguez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #74 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$68.99
Cristian Hernandez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #92 Navy Nameplate from 2025 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Third Base vs. New York Mets on May 16, 2025
Almost Gone!
$344.99
Pittsburgh Pirates Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Second Base vs. Philadelphia Phillies on June 7, 2025 - Innings 1-3
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Third Base vs. New York Mets on May 17, 2025
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Second Base vs. New York Mets on May 18, 2025
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Third Base vs. New York Mets on May 18, 2025
Almost Gone!
$344.99
Pittsburgh Pirates Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Third Base vs. Philadelphia Phillies on June 7, 2025 - Innings 1-3
Almost Gone!
$3,103.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Beige Camo New Era Cap vs. New York Mets on May 18, 2025 - Armed Forces Day
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Second Base vs. New York Mets on May 17, 2025
Almost Gone!
$2,413.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Beige Camo New Era Cap vs. New York Mets on May 18, 2025 - Armed Forces Day
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Third Base vs. Texas Rangers on May 20-22, 2025
Almost Gone!
$102.99
Fernando Cruz New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Worn Light Beige Camo New Era Cap vs. New York Mets on May 18, 2025 - Armed Forces Day
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Second Base vs. Texas Rangers on May 20-22, 2025
Almost Gone!
$33.99
Texas Rangers Fanatics Authentic Dirt Key Chain - Filled with Game-Used Dirt from a Home Game
Arizona DiamondbacksBaltimore OriolesChicago White SoxCincinnati RedsColorado RockiesDetroit Tigers