100% Official Merchandise
365 Day Returns
  1. MLB
  2. New York Yankees
  3. Fanatics Authentic
  4. Top Fan Gifts
1 - 72 of 345
Top Fan Gifts
345 Items
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Athletics on June 27, 2025
$102.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. New York Mets on May 17, 2025
$413.99
Aaron Judge New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic 2024 American League MVP Framed 20" x 24" Collage with Pieces of Game-Used Baseball, Base and Dirt from the 2024 Season
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Tampa Bay Rays on July 28, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Atlanta Braves on July 18, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Tampa Bay Rays on July 29, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. New York Mets on July 5, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Tampa Bay Rays on July 31, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Toronto Blue Jays on July 22, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Toronto Blue Jays on July 21, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Atlanta Braves on July 19, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Philadelphia Phillies on July 26, 2025
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Seattle Mariners on July 10, 2025
Almost Gone!
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Toronto Blue Jays on April 25, 2025
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Seattle Mariners on July 9, 2025
Almost Gone!
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Seattle Mariners on July 8, 2025
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Kansas City Royals on April 14, 2025
Almost Gone!
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Chicago Cubs on July 13, 2025
Almost Gone!
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Chicago Cubs on July 11, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Toronto Blue Jays on July 2, 2025
Almost Gone!
$4,138.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #24 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Chicago Cubs on July 13, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,103.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Tan/Black Louisville Slugger Broken Bat vs. Toronto Blue Jays on April 25, 2025
Almost Gone!
$3,448.99
Max Fried New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #54 Gray Nike Jersey vs. New York Mets on July 6, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Toronto Blue Jays on July 3, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Black EvoShield Shin Guards vs. New York Mets on May 18, 2025
Almost Gone!
$3,448.99
Max Fried New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #54 Gray Nike Jersey vs. Toronto Blue Jays on July 1, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Navy EvoShield Shin Guards vs. Milwaukee Brewers on March 30, 2025
Almost Gone!
$5,517.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #11 Gray Nike Jersey vs. New York Mets on July 6, 2025
Almost Gone!
$2,068.99
Paul Goldschmidt New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$2,758.99
Jazz Chisholm Jr. New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #13 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Chicago Cubs on July 13, 2025
Almost Gone!
$3,448.99
Paul Goldschmidt New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #48 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Chicago Cubs on July 13, 2025
Almost Gone!
$3,448.99
Cody Bellinger New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #35 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Chicago Cubs on July 13, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,034.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Gray New Balance Cleats vs. Cleveland Guardians on April 23, 2025
Almost Gone!
$827.99
Luke Weaver New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #30 Gray Nike Jersey vs. New York Mets on July 6, 2025
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$689.99
Carlos Rodón New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #55 Gray Nike Jersey vs. Toronto Blue Jays on June 30, 2025 - Worn Innings 4-5
Almost Gone!
$482.99
Paul Goldschmidt New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Chicago Cubs on July 11, 2025 - RBI Double
Almost Gone!
$2,758.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Pink EvoShield Chest Protector vs. Athletics on May 11, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Cody Bellinger New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,034.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used White New Balance Cleats vs. Toronto Blue Jays on April 27, 2025 - Game Two of Doubleheader
Almost Gone!
$2,413.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Gray EvoShield Shin Guards vs. Pittsburgh Pirates on April 5, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Jazz Chisholm Jr. New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$482.99
Paul Goldschmidt New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Chicago Cubs on July 11, 2025 - RBI Single
Almost Gone!
$827.99
Luke Weaver New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #30 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Chicago Cubs on July 13, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,034.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used White New Balance Cleats vs. Texas Rangers on May 20, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Navy EvoShield Chest Protector vs. Milwaukee Brewers on March 30, 2025
Almost Gone!
$3,448.99
Giancarlo Stanton New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #27 Gray Nike Jersey vs. New York Mets on July 6, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Gray EvoShield Chest Protector vs. Pittsburgh Pirates on April 5, 2025
Almost Gone!
$5,517.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #11 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Chicago Cubs on July 13, 2025
Almost Gone!
$827.99
Carlos Rodón New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #55 Gray Nike Jersey vs. New York Mets on July 5, 2025 - Worn Innings 1-5
Almost Gone!
$827.99
Devin Williams New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #38 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Chicago Cubs on July 13, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Pink EvoShield Shin Guards vs. Athletics on May 11, 2025
Almost Gone!
$102.99
Oswald Peraza New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Worn Light Blue Fourth of July New Era Hat vs. New York Mets on July 4, 2025
Almost Gone!
$413.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Lineup Card vs. Chicago Cubs on July 13, 2025
Almost Gone!
$3,448.99
Max Fried New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #54 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Chicago Cubs on July 12, 2025
Almost Gone!
$206.99
Andy Pettitte New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued #46 White Nameplate from 2019 MLB Spring Training
Almost Gone!
$1,723.99
Masahiro Tanaka New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #19 Gray Jersey vs. Washington Nationals on June 18, 2018
Almost Gone!
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Kansas City Royals on April 16, 2025
Almost Gone!
$551.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Third Base vs. Athletics on June 27-29, 2025
Almost Gone!
$3,448.99
Max Fried New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #54 Gray Nike Jersey vs. Cincinnati Reds on June 25, 2025 - 7 IP, 7 K, W
Almost Gone!
$965.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Worn #28 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Athletics on June 29, 2025
Almost Gone!
$1,379.99
Giancarlo Stanton New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Issued Black Marucci Broken Bat from the 2022 MLB Season - JD805825
Almost Gone!
$689.99
Devin Williams New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Player-Worn #38 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Athletics on June 29, 2025
Almost Gone!
$827.99
Luke Weaver New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #30 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Athletics on June 29, 2025
Almost Gone!
$3,448.99
Paul Goldschmidt New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #48 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Athletics on June 29, 2025
Almost Gone!
$827.99
Clarke Schmidt New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #36 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Athletics on June 28, 2025
Almost Gone!
$3,448.99
Cody Bellinger New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #35 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Athletics on June 29, 2025 - 3-5, HR, 3 RBI, 3 R
Almost Gone!
$4,138.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used #24 White Pinstripe Nike Jersey vs. Athletics on June 29, 2025
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Baltimore Orioles on June 22, 2025
Almost Gone!
$68.99
New York Yankees Fanatics Authentic Game-Used Baseball vs. Athletics on June 29, 2025